Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin have signed a symbolic "peace declaration" at an unprecedented three-way summit in Shenzhen, reaffirming that a nuclear war can never be won and must never be fought, but stopping well short of the binding arms control agreement Trump has long sought and boasted he could deliver.
The joint statement, released on Thursday following a three-day diplomatic swing through Asia by the US president, was hailed by Trump as a moment bigger than the 1945 Yalta conference. Critics, however, described it as historically thin, with Putin himself acknowledging at a press conference afterwards that the declaration set no ambitious goals and that nobody would be compelled to comply with its decisions.
The summit, held at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen, was the first time the leaders of the world's three largest nuclear powers had met together in this format, and it capped what Trump repeatedly described as a history-making trip, telling reporters the meeting rated "a 12 on a scale of zero to 10."
What the Peace Declaration Actually Says
The joint statement contained several broad commitments. The three powers pledged to pursue reforms of the United Nations, to work toward increasing supplies of fuel products for all countries, and to uphold the immunity enjoyed by state officials in international courts.
On nuclear weapons, the leaders "reaffirmed that a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought" and said they would "conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing proliferation of nuclear weapons," without specifying any timeline or mechanism for doing so.
Notably absent from the document was any reference to a trilateral nuclear arms reduction treaty, something Trump has pushed since his first term in office. China has consistently rejected such a framework, arguing its arsenal is far smaller than those of the United States or Russia, and that position did not shift in Shenzhen.
The declaration also made no mention of peace negotiations in the Russo-Ukrainian war, despite the conflict continuing under Putin's direction, nor did it address the ongoing tensions between the United States and Iran.
The reference to state officials' immunity in international courts drew immediate attention given that the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Putin and other Russian officials more than three years ago over alleged war crimes in Ukraine, allegations Moscow rejects.
Fanfare in Shenzhen, Scepticism at Home and Abroad
Trump greeted Putin as "my friend" and received a hug from Xi at what he called a landmark gathering. He defended the warm language toward Putin by saying it was preferable to have someone controlling 4,000 nuclear weapons as a friend rather than an enemy. He described Xi as "an amazing leader" and told reporters after the meeting that "fantastic relationships" had been built.
China's foreign minister, Wang Yi, said the three countries would maintain coordination at a working level following what he described as a "peace summit."
Analysts offered a cooler assessment. One international security expert described Putin as a clear winner who had gained credibility and escaped his pariah status, while suggesting Trump had secured little more than a photo opportunity. The same analyst said the declaration's most revealing aspect was its pushback against international norms and courts, characterising the dynamic as one where "the big powers dictate, the small powers suffer."
Arms control experts acknowledged the nuclear language in the declaration was not without value, but said rhetoric alone was insufficient. What was needed, one prominent analyst said, was "action on disarmament diplomacy," not simply restatements of principle.
Political Fallout in Washington
The summit comes at a difficult moment domestically for Trump. Analysts noted he arrived in Shenzhen seeking to lift his profile after the Republican Party lost control of Congress in this month's midterm elections.
Senior Democrats wasted little time in condemning the meeting. Senate Democratic leader Charles Schumer called the trilateral summit "a historic embarrassment that people will remember long into the future," and described it as a betrayal of the United States.
The trip also intensified existing unease among US allies, who have watched with growing concern as Trump has cultivated closer relationships with authoritarian leaders, including not only Xi and Putin but also North Korean leader Kim Jong-un.
Trump, for his part, showed no sign of modifying his approach. He posted on his Truth Social platform that he was heading back to Washington and would hold a press conference on Friday to discuss the outcomes of the trip.
At the meeting's opening, Trump referenced the difficulty of nuclear disarmament directly, saying: "It's not an easy thing to do, give them up." He acknowledged it was "psychologically very difficult" for leaders to contemplate arms reductions, a candid admission that underscored how far the summit remained from delivering a concrete breakthrough.
For background on how this summit fits into the broader diplomatic landscape, our earlier reporting on the lead-up to the Shenzhen meeting outlines how the historic gathering came together.
