The Brisbane Broncos face one of the most consequential selection decisions in their recent history as they attempt to identify a halfback worthy of succeeding retired captain Adam Reynolds, with the race to claim the number seven jersey set to define coach Michael Maguire's prospects at the club beyond 2027.
Reynolds, who will remain at Red Hill in a coaching capacity, leaves a twin void: a halfback and a skipper. Brisbane endured a catastrophic 2026 season, recording victories in just three of their final 16 games and finishing 14th, the worst campaign by a defending NRL premier in the competition's modern era.
Who takes the captaincy?
While the halfback question looms as the more complex puzzle, finding a captain to replace Reynolds appears more straightforward. A number of candidates have been named internally, including Mitch Barnett, Kotoni Staggs, Billy Walters and Ben Hunt. However, prop Pat Carrigan is understood to be the frontrunner, with his current contract running through to 2028.
Carrigan made his ambitions plain during Australia's World Cup camp. "It's a privilege to be captain of the Broncos, and if that opportunity was to come, I'd take it with both hands and lead the club forward," he said. "I've always prided myself on not changing and being true to who I am. Success is what you chase, but the hiccups and bumps are what make you a better person."
Pezet: the anointed successor seeking a fresh start
Jonah Pezet was specifically recruited in 2025 as Reynolds' designated replacement, arriving with strong credentials from Melbourne Storm, where he won 13 of his 18 NRL appearances. His 2026 season with Parramatta, however, was derailed by hamstring and shoulder injuries that restricted him to just seven first-grade games.
Now 23, Pezet returned to pre-season training in November for the first time in nearly five years, encouraged by a clean run of fitness since round 12 of the previous season. He spoke optimistically about his physical condition. "It's been tough, the injury stuff that I've been through, but I'm in a good spot now," he said. "To come back in November and really get some good running under my belt, put some weight back on and be comfortable in my body."
Pezet pointed to Brisbane assistant coach Trent Barrett, a former 295-game halfback, as a key influence in his decision to move to Queensland, describing Barrett as a "special mind." Despite joining a club that had fallen sharply from its premiership heights, Pezet refused to frame his move as a salvage operation. "We still have a premiership outfit. This roster and club is built on success, that's on us now to build this," he said.
He also noted a structural advantage heading into 2027: unlike the previous year when players returned in January with barely a month before the World Club Challenge, the squad now has roughly four months of pre-season preparation before their opening fixture.
Duffy: the in-house contender who seized his moment
While Pezet was finding his feet elsewhere, Tom Duffy quietly built a case of his own. A round six performance against North Queensland Cowboys illustrated his credentials vividly: a composed field goal, two try assists and five from five in the kicking tee. The match announced him as a genuine rival for the starting role.
Having been shuffled across halfback, five-eighth and even hooker throughout his early career, Duffy is eager to settle permanently at number seven. "I just feel comfortable at the NRL level now," he said. "The evidence of what you did on the field gives you confidence to do it again. I enjoy playing seven."
His ability to cover goal kicking is particularly valuable given that skill set departed with Reynolds. With player availability always carrying risk across a long NRL season, having a halfback capable of maintaining kicking duties adds genuine depth to Brisbane's options.
Maguire will need to resolve the halfback question before the 2027 season kicks off. The decision carries serious weight: get it right, and Brisbane can begin rebuilding toward a premiership challenge; get it wrong, and the pressure on the coaching staff will only intensify.
