Australia's independent monitor of national security legislation has recommended stripping the word "religious" from the legal Definition of terrorism, proposing instead a broader ideology-based framework that its author says better reflects the range of violent threats the country now faces.
The recommendation comes from the final report of a 15-month review by the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM), led by current monitor Jake Blight. The report was provided to the Attorney-General last month and covers proposed changes to Australia's terrorism laws, which have not been substantially updated since they were introduced in 2002 following the September 11 attacks in the United States.
What the Review Actually Proposes
Under current law, a terrorist act must be intended to advance a political, religious or ideological cause. Rather than simply removing "religious" from that list, Blight has proposed a modified approach: retaining the ideological requirement but defining "ideology" in expansive terms that make a separate religious category redundant.
His proposed definition describes ideology as any "set of beliefs or ideas, that may or may not be coherent, that relate to how the world or society is, or should be, understood." That framing would encompass beliefs rooted in nationalism, politics, faith, philosophy or the perceived superiority of one group over another.
Blight argued the change would not narrow the scope of terrorism laws but would stop them lending legitimacy to those who frame their violence in religious terms.
"Having some terrorists recognised in the law as specifically advancing a religious cause gives the offenders exactly what they want," he said. "They claim to be acting in their God's name, to be doing 'holy work'. They use that to recruit others. When we agree with them, we give them false credibility and reinforce their messaging."
Muslim Community Groups Welcome the Recommendation
A broad coalition of Australian Muslim organisations issued a joint statement welcoming the INSLM's finding. The group, which included the Australian Muslim Advocacy Network, the Lebanese Muslim Association, the Islamic Council of Victoria, the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils and several other bodies, said the current legal language causes direct harm to Muslim communities.
"Every time someone in authority says that a motivation is 'religious', it uplifts ISIS, far right and harmful media narratives all at once, by officially perpetuating the false premise that Islam encourages terrorism," the statement said. "This makes all Muslims feel under siege."
The organisations echoed Blight's concern that the existing definition effectively authorises a framing of violence that does not align with their religious values.
Government Signals It Will Not Act on the Key Recommendation
Despite the review's findings, the federal government has indicated it has no intention of amending the religious element of the terrorism definition. Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke, responding to questions earlier this week, was unequivocal.
"The prime minister's already made clear that a change like that is not something that we would make," Burke said.
Why the Review Says the Law Needs Updating
The INSLM review points to a significant shift in the nature of domestic terrorism prosecutions as a core reason for revisiting the definition. Australia's terrorism laws were written in the immediate aftermath of the September 11 attacks, when jihadist-inspired violence was the dominant concern.
Blight's report notes that up until 2021, there had been only one successful conviction of a person motivated by racist or nationalist ideology on a terrorism charge. Since 2021, however, a quarter of terrorism prosecutions have involved that ideological background, reflecting a marked change in the threat landscape.
The monitor argued that the absence of a clear statutory definition of "ideology" leaves the law poorly equipped to address threats from white nationalism, far-right extremism and other non-religious movements. His proposed definition is designed to close that gap while also ending what he described as the law's unintended endorsement of extremist religious framing.
Whether the government ultimately adopts any part of the INSLM's recommendations remains to be seen.
